Banning Minarets

Mosque in Zurich

On November 29th, a referendum was passed in Switzerland to ban the building of minarets. The referendum passed with a 57% majority vote and a 53% voter turnout. Many in the Swiss government have opposed the referendum but according to the Swiss system the referendum will be added to the Constitution.  There are a number of aspects of this recent vote that are troubling.

The Swiss People’s Party, initiators of the referendum, argues that minarets represent a process of Islamization in Europe and thus should be banned.  The campaign poster further emphasized the fear that proponents of the referendum harbored towards Islam and Muslims. The poster showed a women clad in black wearing a niqab standing with a backdrop of minarets shaped as missiles.

With only 4 minarets total in all of Switzerland, many are troubled that there would be large support for this referendum, especially in a country that has a reputation of religious tolerance and has accepted many refugees.  Moreover, the referendum does not ban the building of mosques; it is quite specifically a ban against minarets. Although minarets are no longer used to call the prayer in many Western countries, for many it remains an identifying marker of a mosque. So by banning this symbol,  many Swiss Muslims felt that the referendum sent a message that they are not respected or accepted as a religious group. Opposing Swiss politicians, however,  have attempted to reassure Swiss Muslims that this referendum is “not a rejection of the Muslim community, religion or culture” rather it “reflects fears among the population of Islamic fundamentalist tendencies.” The same politicians emphasize, though, that they do not agree that banning minarets will counter extremist tendencies.

Tariq Ramadan, a prominent Swiss Islamic scholar, argues that what has happened in Switzerland is indicative of a larger European trend. He asserts that Europe is at a crossroads in terms of what it means to be European as Muslim communities are becoming more visible and integrated into European societies.  For Ramadan, each European country has a symbol of this fear: in France it’s the headscarf, in Denmark it’s the cartoons, in Germany it’s the building of mosques.  At the end of the day, however, Ramadan emphasizes that it is incumbent upon Swiss Muslims, and European Muslims in general, to become more active and show their investment in the societies in which they live–that’s how a referendum like this one can be stopped.

What do you think of the banning of minarets? Do religious symbols of non-Christian groups compromise the values of European society? How do you think this ban will affect Switzerland’s reputation for religious tolerance? What do you think the ramifications of the ban will be on other European nations? Please share your comments below.

One thought on “Banning Minarets

  1. what next for muslims a yellow piece of material sewn on to our clothes with a crest moon ,which we must display at all times ,does this remind you of a certain country who also made a certain religion and race wear a certain yellow piece of material to identify themselves their has already been a attempt of a muslim geniocide in europe in 1992 ,bosnia herzergovnia,how many more religions and races must there be scrapegoated and demonized by the evil intolerance of man kind,why cant we as human beings learn to live and love and care in the lords way and to be tolerant and live in peace and respect for each others beliefs and cultures. this hatred by goverments and groups is all perpertrated by the devil, his twisted sicknesss and poison